S03E16 - One of us - Official Discussion Thread.

Discuss Season 3 Episode 16,

One of us, (Juliet centric)

here Very Happy

_________________

Last edited by April_Rose on Thu Apr 12, 2007 3:54 pm; edited 1 time in total

Loved the episode especially the moral police and the flashbacks! Very Happy

The reunion was sweet and the scene where the camp were grouped round was also excellent. Glad Sawyer said that Jack was saving his own ass, he's 100% correct imo.

The promo for the next 5 episodes blowed me away. I truely believe that Lost is at its best at the moment.

_________________

Great episode, I really feel we got some answers about the others - why they kidnap children, why they took Claire, why Ben was so devastated to have cancer, why Juliet is so desperate to go home, what they are doing, how they communicate (or communicated) with the outside world, that Mittelos Bioscience is set up as a powerful and secret corporation which probably gives them access to information not readily available, that they have people living and work - whether recruiting or researching - in the outside world. Also we learned that Juliet - and therefore probably more of the Others - don't know everything, I'm sure she knows more than she is telling, but if she believed until recently that Ben lied about her sister and she only saw the communications hatch after being there three years and only then because she challenged Ben, she doesn't know the whole story.

Some great scenes, likes Sayid and Juliet, and how Sayid and Sawyer worked together, plus it was interesting to learn that Juliet and Goodwyn were sleeping together, the ending was fantastic though, I wasn't sure if I trusted her but I wasn't expecting that - the implant in Claire? They must have had it in mind that they would need it at some stage. I wonder if her plan is to kidnap Aaron, or if Sun now she's pregnant is the main concern?

Also raises more questions about the island itself - no one (until Ben) ever got cancer, but the women are all infertile? And why did Ben get cancer, and why did Claire and Aaron survive - was it Juliet's treatment, or was it the fact that so much of her pregnancy had already passed before she got to the island?

Another hint that Jacob is in fact the head honcho, whoever Jacob is.

Good episode, can't wait for the next one!

_________________

ye a great episode, quite a lot answered yet a lot more questions brought up lol typical lost.

cant wait to see what happens over the next week on the island but if the promo is anything to go by its gonna be explosive!!!

_________________

Omg the ending of this blew me away!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I truly did not see that coming!!!
I guess Jack is right, she wants of the island more than anything and is prepared to DO anything to get off it! What a bitch though!! Just when i was starting to like her!

Lost is getting better and better every week!!!

Yay!!!

I like a bitch and the fact that Julliet is becoming one makes me like her even more.

_________________

Wow.good episode. not amasingly good i must say but not bad at all. shame bout juliet really.just when we were startin do dare i say it warm to her.not like mind you but uno accept her a little an then BOOM they hit u with that shocker.shuda seen it coming really tho i gess. i agrre with tammy she must stil b desperate to go home. shame also that ther wasnt much in the way of any big skate renunion moments, thou the hug was very sweet.sawyers face was jus adorable.anyway bout the hole 'death of pregnant women until claire thing'!? jus curious if anyone knows whether french lady gave birth to alex on the island or was she alreay born when her boat thing crashed? well thas me done for now looking forward to next week.specially if wer gona get some naked sawyerness.

Loved it! But what about the preview for the next lot of episodes! Wow! Love this site btw way too. Thanks to people who run it. Cheers x

a great eps this one i enjoyed juliet is great character after few crappy epiosdes this one was brilliant, when sawyer and jack hugged i thought they wanted beat the hell outta each other.

as it is all a plan to pretend juliet was 'left behind' though, does this mean that what she told jack and kate about ethan and what he was doing is not true? - i also noticed she failed to mention the part when ethan hung charlie

_________________

yeah, I noticed that as well, she was subtly sticking up for Ethan, it's hard to be sure what was true and what wasn't, we saw in her flashbacks that it's true that women die in pregnancy there, but she might have lied about Claire showing symptoms of the same condition, and we know now that one of the things they did to Claire was put in an implant which made her sick so it wasn't withdrawal symptoms from the injection stuff at all. She might have been lying about most of it.

_________________

Although at the end of the last ep, i did suspect Juliet and possibly Jack a little too. Throughout this ep i gradually forgot about that and started believing the things Juliet was saying. Then the big reveal at the end.. brilliant! Left me sitting here saying "I knew it!" lol =]

same here ben is evil he planned to perfection i mean they all know who the surviors are what they did in the past.one thing i dnt get we know that sayid tortured lot of people and they can get the info about that from military record or sumin like that, but when juilet says to sawyer that he killed the man in sydney how the hell they wud know about that coz there wsnt even any 1 there.

Yeah, I've wondered about that as well, their connections seem to be to some shadowy types though so maybe they have some kind of super-PI working for them.

If they know that about Sawyer, I wonder if they know that Jack and Claire are brother and sister? And if so will they reveal it? So far hardly anyone knows about their connections, the only one that really came to light was Sawyer meeting Jack's dad, but generally it's just us the viewers that know about them.

_________________

surely the others must know about jack and claire, it must of come up when they were researching them

_________________

i'd love it if they did, then it would come out because otherwise I don't see how it would as Claire didn't want to know her Dad's name. They must!

_________________

but desmond and jack met in LA didnt they, so when they see each other on the beach or anywhere they wud know that they met back in the real world.how weird.

Yeah that's right, they did recognise each other, but most of the connections it's only the viewers who know about them, maybe the Others do but they just have to know about Claire and jack, if they know about Sawyer killing the man in Sydney then they have to know that.

_________________

ur rite i think they wud know that they are related, i think they have some sort of PI working for them it has to be, in this eps we saw ben talking to sum one on the radio who was in the same place as juilets sister and with a camera.

that is a pretty good connection if you ask me! good spot!

_________________