April_Rose
|
Rate Episode 9give episode 9 marks out of ten
I give it a 7 - not bad for a Jack episode, and the flashbacks gain points from me for tellign us about the tatoos and the girl's line "I'm not interesting in hearing about your father"...just what I was thinking! I laughed out loud at that! Plus there was the kicking on the beach....
my other thoughts on the episode are in the official discussion thread, just wondering what everyone thought.
|
Em_J
|
I gave it a one. But only because zero wasn't an option. I despised and hated this ep with the fiery passion. . . you know the rest.
|
redwinegoblin
|
I'm saying 6/10 - it wasn't as bad as all jack eps usually are, but I was just so indignant at having to learn more about him that it bothered me all the way through!! Especially as there were a few tantalising Kate/Sawyer interactions that were waaaay more interesting than the Jack stuff.
|
Admin1
|
I gave it an 8. I dont think it was as bad as everybody is making out. It was slow at the beginning, and the 3 big mysteries werent actually revealed too well, but overall, I liked it.
The flashbacks were better than the usual daddy issues they usually have, and there were quite alot of wow moments.
The worst thing about this episode though, was the tailies. We hadn't seen them since the start of season 2, then when we finally do, their entrance was pretty much poo! I had been looking forward to seeing the tailies again for ages, especially Cindy, but when we did, I wasn't really even excited.
8/10 may be slightly generous, but I boosted it to average Em's 1/10.
|
Em_J
|
I thought giving it a 1 was being generous!
|
charliefan14
|
I gave it 6/10 i found Jacks flashback was quite dulll my highlight was seeing him get his ass kicked and the mysterys werent as great as they promsied i thought jacks tatoo story would of been more intresting i did like the kate sawyer and karl thing to it intrested me and was weird to see sawyers softer side
|
April_Rose
|
That's an average of 4.89...the 1 and 3 fairly bring it down!
|
Em_J
|
Heh heh! Good! 
|
Xarcabard
|
N/A Because its unfair to rate an episode if you can't stay awake for it all. 
|
April_Rose
|
|
|
|
