Most evil Other so far

April_Rose · Most evil Other so far

Who is the most evil other so far in your opinion?

Goodwyn who let poor nathan suffer, then killed him, to protect his secret?

Ethan, who kidnapped Claire and hung Charlie from a tree, then killed Scott (or was it Steve?)

Tom/Zeke who blew up the raft and stole Walt from Michael?

Fake Henry who we must presume killed real Henry, tempted Locke not to press the button, messed with Locke's mind, tormented Ana, Sayid and anyone else who came near him with his twisted words?

Miss Clugh/Bea, who told Michael to do whatever it took to free Fake Henry and get the people on the list to them?

I'd have to go with Ethan, personally, I think he's been the most ruthless of the lot - when you consider the deception, what he did to poor Charlie, how he kicked the crap out of Jack, kidnapping Claire and holding her, messing with her mind, planning to steal her baby and then kick her out to fend for herself again, then killing Scott/Steve when she escaped...he seems the most callously determined to meet whatever ends he was working toward.

Guest

Ethan, he nearly killed ma baby. Not nice Cry

angelfairy

i think im gonna have to go with Fhenry cause he creeps the hell out of me Ethan is definitely a close second

Admin1

Ethan gets my vote - he beat up Jack, hung charlie, killed scott / steve lol, and kidnapped claire, i dont like henry either - he looks too much like a china doll when he smiles lol

Guest

Ethan was really scary but at the moment it has to be Fhenry

Guest

i hated ethan he went though me with his evil eyes Sad

angelfairy

Guest

Now we know Fhenry abit better i dont think he's as evil, whereas Ethan was sooo scary

angelfairy

very true.. at least ethan got what he deserved ..a good old shooting by charlie! yay go charlie!!!

Guest

Yeah, can you imagine if Charlie hadnt have shot him though, they might have loooads of info about the others by now

angelfairy

yeah maybe charlie did the wrong thing in a way by shooting ethan they could have made him talk and tell them about the others

Guest

Though i doubt he would've talked, even with torture.. Fhenry didnt after all

angelfairy

yeah and even if ethan had talked he probably would have got killed by fbenry for talking in the first place if we presume that fbenry is the leader of the others

Guest

I don't think that he is the leader, though i think he's quite important

April_Rose

I agree with lost_maniac, I don't think he is the leader, he might be the manager so to speak, but not the owner - I get a feeling that he likes to be in charage but there is soemone else he reports to - it's not soemhting I have any evidence for as such, just a hunch

Guest

got 2 be ethan for me he ws nasty piece of work kinda like the other who does the dirty work 4 them.

Guest

Definately Ethan...he was really creepy and he killed Steve and (well he did) kill Charlie, but then thanks to Dr Jack, half of the cutest couple ever was saved (Thats Charlie and Claire, in case you didnt know Razz

)

Guest

Haha, the bit where Ethan came back for Claire and stormed out of the jungle, that gave me nightmares for weeks :[
then Charlie shot him :]]]

Guest

i gotta say ethan is the most evil by far, look what he did to charlie and claire and which one was it scott or steve lol

Guest

Ethan was freaky. I don't like how he hung Charlie whatsoever,

Cloverfield

Was going to vote for Pickett, but he's not on the list Confused

redwinegoblin

He's pretty evil....but it's gotta be Bhenry - the man defines creepyness!! Just his face gives me the wiggins!

Cloverfield

Yh, Fenry is pretty evil and devious.

legallyblonde01

Yay Benry!

Jenny*

pickett . . . was a meany man Sad