S03E17 - Catch 22 Official Discussion Thread

Register

So. . . what did everybody think of the new ep??

I could've done without seeing Charlie speared through the neck quite so many times! Laughing

Was a good ep though, interesting Desmond stuff.

_________________

I liked it, but I wasn't too keen on the flashbacks. The arrow through the neck was great I thought. I was dissapointed that it was just Desmonds visions.

Even Jack didn't annoy me in this episode (thats a first) and its always good seeing a lot of Kate Very Happy

The episode just missed a bit of oomph it wasn't bad but could have done with a few more revelations.

_________________

Jack always annoys me. Smug-faced git that he is! Kate actually annoyed me in this ep, stringing Sawyer along! Hussy!

I love the fact that Desmond got fired from the monastery! Laughing

_________________

Me too!

And yeah Kate did annoy me a little too, I don't like what the producers have been doing with her in the last few episodes.

I actually liked Charlie a little in this episode, I don't want him to die as much now Surprised

_________________

Yep, I liked Charlie in this ep, wasn't acting as stupid as he usually does, he seemed a little more clued in to what Desmond was up to.

_________________

Hi I'm I being thick!! Where is the media section??? It seems to have disappeared! x

i did like this episode but it wasent as exciting as the preview made it out to be. And i think they showed charlie getting speared in the neck a bit to much lol

but it was a good episode, i think it will start getting really good!!!

_________________
www.JohnnyDepp-Fan.com // www.ChanningTatumOnline.com // www.FrankieMunizWeb.net // www.LeonardoOnline.net

www.henrycusick.com <---download Desmond clips here!!!!

^^ My Websites ^^

i loved this one desmonds eps always rocks, but not really sure out the flashback was a wee bit boring, i mean do we really need to know how did he get the habit of saying brutha all he time, i dnt think so.loved the secne where penny and des meet for the first time.

He wasn't moping either.

I haven't liked it in recent weeks when he's been feeling sorry for himself.

_________________

Sorry about that miss chief, it's sorted for you again now!

I liked it, not brilliant, but it was good. Jack annoyed me when Desmond was asking for the first aid kit, but he always annoys me. I wasn't too impressed with Kate either but at least Sawyer brought her up on it.

The flashbacks were decent, as we didn't know Desmond had been a monk, and it confirmed what we saw in him before, that he believes there's a reason for the stuff that's happening.

I had a feeling Pen would have sent someone else first, I wonder who the girl is?

Didn't mind the shots of Charlie being shot through the neck, glad Desmond finally saved him though.

Good episode and it'll be interesting to see how they develop it. Can Sayid fix the Sat phone I wonder?

_________________

I agree with all that! Lol.

So yeah... It was on OK episode.. could have been a lot better though.

_________________

Jack is annoying! Hes really cranky!

_________________
Users are not allowed signatures when they first join

well guys,not one of the greatest episodes of the season im afraid i must say.i mean it was alrite i mean it was good but it dint get my heart racing i hav to say.evn with th hole charlies supposed death thing, itr was a bit like yeah like we dint see that coming. i hav to say part of th reason i may b feelin slighty neagativ cud largely b due to the hole kates treatment of sawyer especally as he was bein really lovely an sweet in this episode (part from mybe th hole lets hav sex bit).i thought it was so mature of him how it dealt wiv it tho, evn tho he was obviusly hurtin.an i loved seeing him play ping-pong wiv jack.hes really come along way to b able to do that.anyway as far as otha things go.dessy's fb was dull as really an how obvious was it that th women who fell from the sky was not gona b penny but is workin for her.rite thas it im done

Plenty of points there bagels! Sawyer did do well to play pingpong with Jack, it'll b e interesting to see how that develops over the next few weeks, especially when Jakc learns Juliet betrayed him.

Yeah, kinda figured Penny would send someone else but I look forward to hearing the girl's story!

_________________