Rate One of Us

Register

Rate S03E16 - One of us - here.

_________________

Last edited by April_Rose on Thu Apr 19, 2007 2:38 pm; edited 2 times in total

Perfect 10, great episode, brilliant acting and great ending.

_________________

9/10 for me, great episode, we learned a lot about the Others, nice twist at the end, we saw a bit of almost everyone and there were different currents running through it, classic Lost!

_________________

9/10 for me as well.

Good episode.

_________________

7/10 for me. I so wanted to hit Jack in that ep!!

_________________

I always want to hit Jack....but yeah, he was particularly annoying. So smug and self righteous.

_________________

Especially when he was talking to Sayid! I was thinking why are you letting him talk to you like that?!

_________________

Yeah, the way people let him act like that annoys me, when he was like that to Sayid he was as well, but I'm not convinced Sayid hasn't got his misgivings about Jack's loyalties overall now. Maybe he's just keeping an eye on him and biding his time!

He was really irritating when he spoke to Charlie as well "i trust her, do you trust me? Wah wah wah?"

_________________

God yeah, forgotten that bit! I was expecting Charlie to say no. Disappointed when he said yeah, even if he hesitated!

_________________

He caved really quickly I thought, I know he and Jack got on well for a while but jack's been away a long time, you'd think he would have been a bit more sceptical, generally he's really overprotective and annoying around Claire, and this was the one time I was hoping for that so he'd tell Jack where to go! Considering too that when Ethan was injecting Claire jack told her she was hallucinating!

_________________

Exactly! I'll be quite happy for Jack to pop his clogs any time soon. He just makes me mad! He's so stupid!

_________________

The worst part for me was when Jack said "the fact that I trust her should be enough" thats just so aggrogant imo and shows how little he cares about everyone elses opinions.

_________________

Grr! Yeah, he puts me near my rage. I certianly wouldn't have been as happy as the rest of them to see his huge head walking back into camp!

_________________

Yeah, he really is incredibly arrogant, it would be so great if he accidentally fell off a cliff or something....or any kind of death really, I'd even take a so-called noble death if it meant we never had to look at his smug, patronising face again!

_________________

Yeah I can't stand the sight of him either and even though he's the main character the show would just be sooo much better without him.

_________________

it really would, Sawyer, Hurley, Sayid, Locke, Kate, Charlie, even Sun and Jin are much better characters with much more interesting complexity, I don't get the feeling we want to know anything else about him, he's a doctor, he likes to fix stuff, he acts patronising toward women and people in general, he likes to act the martyr, and he has Daddy issues - enough already! He's gotten way more flashbacks than anyone else, and there are other people we want to learn more about, that are much more mysterious and interesting. If anything, I'd say Locke should be the main character - he's the one who was cured by the island, even if he can be annoying sometimes as well he doesn't make me shout at the Tv like Jack does!

_________________

i gave it a 10, thought it was amazing! loved the ending!

i can't wait for them to figure out that juliet ending up there was all a plan - jack will be hated (i like jack - but it will be interesting to see if he is exiled or something)

_________________

yeah, that will be an interesting turn of events - people certainly won't trust him after that! Laughing

_________________

I wonder what is going to happen in a week (lost time) from what Julliet and Ben were saying.

_________________

yeah, i hope we find out next week instead of it being put back - does anyone know whos flashback it is next week by the way? i know the episode is called catch 22

_________________